Imperative Sentences (Commands) With Stated Subjects?

Elizabeth O'Brien

Hello! I'm Elizabeth O'Brien, and my goal is to get you jazzed about grammar. 

Learn More

Imperative Sentences (Commands)
With Stated Subjects?

How well do you know imperative sentences? In this lesson, we're going over something that can be kind of confusing about them. Are you ready? Great! 

Here's the sentence we'll be studying: 

Bob, walk the dog. 

Before we look at how categorizing this sentence can be confusing, let's review what imperative sentences are. 

Imperative Sentence Refresher

Imperative sentences give commands. 

  • Walk the dog.
  • Open the door. 
  • Please wipe your feet. 

Notice that imperative sentences don't state the subject of the sentence. (Remember that subjects tell us whom or what a sentence is about.) While these guys don't state the subject, they do have a subject. Their subject is the implied word you, which we call you understood

  • (you) Walk the dog. 
  • (you) Open the door.
  • (you) Please wipe your feet.

If you think about it, this makes sense because when you're giving a command, you're speaking to someone. That someone is the subject, and we name them with the pronoun you

Commands With Stated Subjects?

Now, let's get to the tricky part. What happens when we take a command and add the name of the person we are addressing?

  • Bob, walk the dog.
  • Tess, open the door. 
  • Oden, please wipe your feet.

Are these sentences still commands, or are they now statements because they seem to have a named subject?

Bob Ross Grammar

To answer this question, we need to learn about one more grammatical concept called nouns of direct address.

Nouns of Direct Address

Nouns of direct address are nouns that address the person or thing you are speaking to. They are not subjects of sentences. 

  • Bob, walk the dog.
  • Tess, open the door. 
  • Oden, please wipe your feet.

Remember that the subject of all imperative sentences is (you). This remains true even when we begin an imperative sentence with a noun of direct address

  • Bob, (you) walk the dog. 
  • Tess, (you) open the door.
  • Oden, (you) please wipe your feet. 

It is a coincidence that in these cases the noun of direct address and the subject (you) are referring to the same person. However, that doesn't mean that you can use them interchangeably as subjects.

The bottom line is that commands will never have stated subjects.

Their subjects are always understood you. When you begin a command naming the person you are addressing, that noun is called a noun of direct address. It is a noun, but it is not the subject. 

Does that seem strange?

Does it still seem like nouns of direct address should be subjects when used with commands? If so, here's something helpful to consider. 

Check out these declarative sentences that begin with nouns of direct address. I have underlined the subjects for you. 

Tom, the fall is a beautiful time of year.

Jerry, water freezes at 32 degrees Fahrenheit.

Yikes! If we treated nouns of direct address as subjects, we wouldn't know if the subjects were Tom and Jerry or fall and water

Luckily, we don't have to worry about this because nouns of direct address are never subjects. Whew!

Bob Ross sentence diagram

P.S. If you're wondering how to diagram that sentence, here's Bob Ross showing us how it's done.

Thanks for your help, Bob! I knew you were a painter, but I didn't know you also diagrammed sentences.

If you want to teach or learn grammar the easy way, follow our step-by-step program which clearly lays everything out and allows you to move at your own pace. The Get Smart Grammar Program is presented in a logical sequence, so it's not an overwhelming mishmash of information. Just watch the videos and complete your assignments. Before you know it, you'll be a grammar and sentence diagramming pro!

The Get Smart Grammar Program
Elizabeth O'Brien from Grammar Revolution

If you don't want to teach or learn grammar by yourself,  click here to see how I can help you.

Like many, I adore your program. I have a BA in English, an MA in Psychology, and am a certified TEFL instructor. Yet NONE of those marvelous programs taught me grammar!

Thank you, Elizabeth. THANK YOU, THANK YOU, THANK YOU. (You're a rock star!)

My students, by the way, also adore your program!

- Michelle, Adult ESL Teacher

The Beginner's Guide to Grammar Ebook

Our Free Guide Gives You A Fun Way

To Teach And Learn The Basics v

Download Now
Elizabeth O'Brien

Elizabeth O'Brien is the creator of Grammar Revolution.

Her lessons are guaranteed to give you more confidence in your communication skills and make you smile. :)

Learn More About Sentence Types

Back to English Grammar Home